Spying on Chats? Facebook Confirms It Scans Your Messenger
The private messages Facebook users send to each other through Messenger aren't so private.
Facebook, already under fire for how it handles profile data, confirmed to Bloomberg on Wednesday that it scans the text and images people send to one another on Messenger to make sure it follows the company's content rules.
And it blocks messages that don't comply.
The company said it uses the same automated tools to scan Messenger for abuse as it does on Facebook in general.
"For example, on Messenger, when you send a photo, our automated systems scan it using photo matching technology to detect known child exploitation imagery or when you send a link, we scan it for malware or viruses," a Facebook Messenger spokeswoman said in a statement to Bloomberg. "Facebook designed these automated tools so we can rapidly stop abusive behavior on our platform."
The company told Bloomberg it doesn't use data from scanned messages for advertising.
Concerns about whether Facebook was snooping on Messenger rose this week after the site's founder, Mark Zuckerberg, alluded to it in a interview with Vox's Erza Klein . Zuckerberg told Klein about stopping sensational messages about ethnic cleansing in Myanmar being sent through Messenger.
Facebook launched Messenger as a stand-alone app in 2014. That same year, Facebook paid $19 billion for WhatsApp, a chat app similar to Messenger. Messenger topped 1 billion monthly users in 2017. WhatsApp had 1 billion daily users in 2017.
WhatsApp encrypts messages on both ends of the conversation, so the company cannot see them, according to Bloomberg.
Facebook has been under intense scrutiny since news broke that private information from about 50 million users was accessed by Cambridge Analytica, a political consulting firm with connections to President Donald Trump's 2016 campaign. Zuckerberg agreed to testify before Congress next week.
The company also announced Wednesday a slew of changes to its privacy policies.
Almost always, critics say, the changes meant a move away from protecting user privacy and toward pushing openness and more sharing. On the other hand, regulatory and user pressure has sometimes led Facebook to pull back on its data collection and use and to explain things in plainer language -- in contrast to dense legalese circulated by many other internet companies.
Among the changes:
--Facebook has added a section explaining that it collects people's contact information if they choose to "upload, sync or import" this to the service. This may include users' address books on their phones, as well as their call logs and text histories. The new policy says Facebook may use this data to help "you and others find people you may know."
--The previous policy did not mention call logs or text histories. Several users were surprised to learn recently that Facebook had been collecting information about whom they texted or called and for how long, though not the actual contents of text messages. It seemed to have been done without explicit consent, though Facebook says it only collected such data from Android users who specifically allowed it to do so -- for instance, by agreeing to permissions when installing Facebook.
© 2018 Pittsburgh Tribune-Review under contract with NewsEdge/Acquire Media. All rights reserved.
Image credit: Facebook; iStock/Artist's concept.
Posted: 2018-04-09 @ 1:07pm PT
@Peer - I understand your point, but this also puts the burden on users, most of whom just don't have the time to deal with the numerous corporate violations of consumer rights. Let's not forget it is not the user that has done anything wrong. Facebook has, and it needs to be more tightly regulated.
In fact, I am not even sure if deleting your account would do much good, as I have noticed that if you change your email address, facebook keeps the old one on record and is therefore still able to link your profile data to requests from app developers or companies for targeted advertising. Indeed, what I find most infuriating about this whole situation, is that there is no way – to my knowledge – to contact facebook to request certain data to be permanently removed from their records.
If facebook wants to show it takes user’s concerns and privacy seriously it should offer complete control to users of the data that they have shared with facebook. And if they don’t want to do this voluntarily, they should be forced and enforced to do so by regulation.
Posted: 2018-04-08 @ 5:40am PT
@Johs Lock - You seem to be optimistic about change from above (politics). I agree with your frustration but I think politics has no interest in securing our data. The user has to boycott these companies so that they are put under pressure from below. Just turn away from Facebook and its data-sucking daughters and son (instagram, whatsapp, fb-messenger). It is not difficult to boycott an insecure messenger as there are many alternatives. Just pick a group of friends and move to Signal or even better Threema. Nowadays, users have to go for a change and not trust in politics and big-techs "good will" anymore.
Posted: 2018-04-06 @ 4:27am PT
@Johs Lock - I agree 100% with you! ("So if I choose not to share my mobile phone number with facebook, how the hell do they think I give permission to access and retrieve my mobile phone contact list!?")
Posted: 2018-04-06 @ 4:09am PT
I recently requested a copy of my facebook data and was shocked to see it contained my entire phone contact list!
In your article you write "--Facebook has added a section explaining that it collects people's contact information if they choose to "upload, sync or import" this to the service. This may include users' address books on their phones, as well as their call logs and text histories. The new policy says Facebook may use this data to help "you and others find people you may know.""
Contrary to what you state in your article, "I never choose to 'upload, sync or import' this data to facebook." In fact, I never choose to reveal my mobile phone number to facebook, despite the fact that they keep reminding me "to complete my profile". My mobile phone number is still not registered as part of my profile.
So if I choose not to share my mobile phone number with facebook, how the hell do they think I give permission to access and retrieve my mobile phone contact list!?
It is clear that you cannot trust facebook at all. They basically steal your data without your consent. In the non-Internet world that would be a violation of the law, but it seems the Internet is the new Wild West. It is time regulatory agencies start doing their job and enforce the law.